Why Scots Live in England Despite Disliking the English

Have you ever wondered why Scots, who are often known to dislike the English, still opt to live in England? It's a complex question that goes beyond tribalism and media bias. This article explores the reasons behind this paradox, shedding light on the nuanced relationship between the two nations.

The Reality Behind Dislikes

There's a prevailing notion that many Scots harbour a deep-seated dislike for the English. However, as discussed by various Scots who have experienced life in England, this hatred is often more complicated than it seems. As one Scottish individual noted, "When I was growing up in Scotland, we used to say we hated the English. The reality was that we didn't, but we weren't too fond of the very biased English-centric media." This sentiment points to a broader issue of media representation and how it can influence public opinion.

Real-Life Experiences

Personal experiences often provide a more accurate picture of cross-border relations. For instance, when moving to Plymouth, Devon, in 2007 after being posted by the Royal Navy, the individual found that "I’ve since befriended many English people with my wife being English too. The thing is, I’ve been here that long now, I no longer see them as English. To me, they’re just people." These anecdotes suggest that the lack of animosity towards the English is primarily due to personal experiences and interactions, rather than a blanket disapproval.

Historical and Sociopolitical Context

The historical and political backgrounds influence how people perceive others. In the case of Scots, there is a long history of mutual respect and friendship despite cultural differences. "The Scots are British but are not English and would never claim to be. The friendly antipathy and mutual disrespect between English and Scots mark us as being different, but the Scots are great friends and neighbours, even if they are not English." This perspective highlights the importance of distinguishing between political union and cultural identity.

The Conundrum of Brain Drain and Work Opportunities

Another reason many Scots choose to live in England is due to economic and professional opportunities. The article mentions that “many Scots are sent to work in London, which is unfortunately for the time being our capital city too as well as yours. It's called brain drain, which is a real thing and another problem with this union.” This suggests that career advancement and employment opportunities play a significant role in the decision to live in England, despite any disliking of the English.

Personal and Professional Motivations

While sport and cultural differences may sometimes be conflated, personal and professional reasons often take precedence. "It’s a bit cringe to be living there but hating it," emphasizes the importance of balancing one's personal sentiments with the benefits of living in a different country. Work opportunities, especially in major cities like London, often outweigh individual dislikes towards the English.

Conclusion

The question “Why do Scots live in England despite disliking the English?” is more complex than it appears. It encompasses issues of media representation, personal experiences, historical context, and economic motivations. By understanding these factors, we can appreciate the nuanced relationship between Scots and the English, and the reasons behind Scots choosing to live in England.