Why Germany Should Not Ally with Russia to Annex Poland and Prussia

In the realm of geopolitical strategy, the idea of Germany and Russia allying to annex Poland and subsequently divide Poland while reclaiming Prussia may seem appealing. However, several critical factors make this plan highly unlikely and fraught with challenges. This article delves into why such an alliance is not a viable option under current geopolitical conditions and historical context.

Historical Context and Current Geopolitical Realities

The current landscape of Eastern Europe and the European Union has significantly altered the dynamics that existed in the 1930s and 1940s. Let us examine why an alliance between Germany and Russia to annex and partition Poland, as suggested, would face insurmountable obstacles.

Why Poland Cannot Be Annexed or Divided

One of the primary reasons why such an alliance faces severe challenges is the current military capabilities and political stability of Poland. Poland, bolstered by its NATO membership and robust governmental structures, is better equipped to defend itself against any potential external aggression. Even if both Russia and Germany were to collaborate against Poland, the scenario of Poland falling under such circumstances is extremely improbable. Poland has a modern, well-organized military, and its army is larger than Germany's.

The Historical and Legal Implications of Annexing Prussia and Baltic Territories

The historical claims and current legal status of territories such as Prussia and Baltic regions are complex. It is important to recognize that the annexation of regions like Prussia, traditionally considered part of the Lithuanian and Baltic territories, is fraught with historical and legal disputes. The original Prussians were indeed Baltic people, not German, and their territories were taken through brutal means by the Teutonic Knights during the Christian Crusades to spread Christianity to the Baltic peoples.

Furthermore, Russia's current occupation of parts of Lithuania, such as Smolensk, is considered illegal by many international legal bodies. The concept of dividing a hostile country (Poland) between allies, as suggested, is not only unethical but also politically and diplomatically unviable. Such actions would likely destabilize the region and lead to widespread opposition from the international community and especially from the NATO countries.

The Failure of Previous Alliances

Historical precedents, such as the German-Russian Nazi alliance of the 1930s, have proven to be disastrous and ultimately led to the downfall of both nations. The annexation of half of Prussia by the USSR after 1945 is a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of such actions. The idea of resurrecting such an alliance is not only unwelcome but also inadvisable given the mounting tensions and the current geopolitical climate.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the idea of Germany and Russia allying to annex Poland and subsequently divide Poland and reclaim Prussia is not only impractical but also ethically and legally questionable. Current geopolitical realities and historical precedents strongly discourage such an alliance. It is more prudent for nations to focus on diplomatic strategies, mutual respect, and cooperation to ensure lasting peace and stability in the region.