How does Ron DeSantis’ Handling of Hurricane Idalia Compare to Other Florida Governors?

Florida has a long history of dealing with hurricanes, and each governor faces unique challenges during these crises. This article compares Ron DeSantis' response to Hurricane Idalia with the actions of other Florida governors who faced similar hurricanes during their tenures.

Preparation is Key in Florida

The people of Florida are adept at preparing for hurricanes. Households are stocked with essentials like water, non-perishable food, and camping gear. Local communities have well-established emergency plans and evacuation routes. Even those who stay put during hurricanes have contingencies, such as using charcoal grills and keeping cash handy for essential goods.

DeSantis’ Proactive Approach

When Hurricane Idalia approached, Governor DeSantis was no exception. He was proactive in his preparations. Before the hurricane made landfall, DeSantis issued state-of-emergency orders, evacuated coastal areas, and warned residents of potential flooding. This early action aimed to minimize the risk of loss of lives and property.

Challenges and Criticisms

DeSantis could not always be on the ground during the storm, as he was running for president at the time. This has led to criticisms, especially given how visible other governors were during major crises. For example, the photo of DeSantis carrying a bucket in seemingly symbolic cleanup efforts after Hurricane Irma was met with skepticism. This didn’t reflect the realities of the situation, where immediate and efficient response is crucial.

Comparing DeSantis to Other Governors

Other Florida governors have faced similar situations with varying degrees of preparedness and public engagement. For example:

Charlie Crist: During Hurricanes Wilma in 2005 and Irene in 2011, Crist was highly visible, touring damaged areas and coordinating relief efforts. His public presence during these crises helped establish a culture of preparedness and unity. Charlie Hull: In 2004, Hull was criticized for his response to Hurricane Charley, which led to significant criticism from the public and media. However, his successors learned from these experiences, improving state-wide emergency responses. Rick Scott: During Hurricane Michael in 2018, Scott faced similar criticism. However, Scott’s administration was praised for its able and timely evacuation, despite Scott’s apparent initial inaction.

The Role of Governor in a Crisis

During a major hurricane, a governor must balance multiple responsibilities. Firstly, ensuring public safety is a top priority. Secondly, coordinating relief efforts and providing timely updates to the public. Thirdly, maintaining a high profile to gain public support for the next election. DeSantis was in a challenging position during Hurricane Idalia, but his response aimed to address these three key areas.

Conclusion

The response to Hurricane Idalia by Ron DeSantis can be evaluated against the actions of other Florida governors. While DeSantis received criticism, his early preparations and state-of-emergency declarations were proactive. The role of a governor in a crisis is multifaceted, and DeSantis’ approach aimed to address public safety, relief coordination, and political considerations.

Keywords: Ron DeSantis, Hurricane Idalia, Florida governors